Your Cart is Empty
FREE DELIVERY | 100% HAPPINESS GUARANTEE
FREE DELIVERY | 100% HAPPINESS GUARANTEE
July 04, 2026 6 min read
TL;DR: Frosty Paws is the grocery-aisle frozen dog dessert most people know, but it is dairy-based, sweetened, and around 140 to 150 calories per cup, which is a lot for a small or medium dog. If you want alternatives, you have three paths: other store-bought "dog ice cream" cups, the homemade yogurt-and-fruit route, and meat-based frozen treats you make at home. For an everyday frozen treat (not a once-a-year birthday splurge), the cleaner picks are dairy-free, low-sugar, and portion-controlled. We make one of those, but you do not need us to do this well at home.
Frosty Paws has been in freezer aisles since the late 1970s, and for a lot of dog owners it is the default frozen treat. It works. Dogs like it. But people come looking for alternatives for a few common reasons: the calories add up fast, the dairy upsets some dogs, the sugar bothers owners watching their dog's weight, or the price per cup feels high for something that is mostly water and whey.
Whatever the reason, there are good options. This guide walks through the store-bought competitors, the homemade route, and how to think about which one fits your dog. We will be fair about Frosty Paws along the way, it is not a bad product, it is just built to be a sweet dessert rather than an everyday snack.
The usual reasons, in rough order of how often we hear them:
If you want the full ingredient breakdown before shopping for alternatives, we wrote one up in our Frosty Paws recipe breakdown.
Several brands now make frozen "dog ice cream" cups and mixes. They mostly fall into a few categories.
A handful of brands sell ready-to-eat frozen cups similar to Frosty Paws, and some powdered mixes you stir with water and freeze. The better ones are lactose-reduced or dairy-free, skip the added sugar, and use recognizable ingredients like yogurt, peanut butter, banana, or pumpkin. The weaker ones still lean on the same whey-and-sweetener formula, just with a different label.
How to tell them apart: read the first three ingredients. If sugar, corn syrup, or a generic "natural flavors" line shows up before the actual food, you are buying a dessert. If real food (yogurt, meat, banana, pumpkin) leads the list, it is a better pick.
These are a step up for most owners. You add water, freeze, and you control the portion size. The dairy-based ones still carry the lactose issue, but the meat- or coconut-based mixes avoid it. Mixes also store on a shelf instead of taking up freezer space until you need them.
Not frozen, but worth mentioning. Freeze-dried meat treats give you the real-meat reward without sugar or dairy. They are not cold, so they do not solve the "hot day" problem, but they pair well with a frozen base.
Honestly, the cheapest reliable Frosty Paws alternative is the one you make yourself. The ingredients are things you probably already have, and the cost per treat is a fraction of any store-bought cup. A few easy versions:
Greek yogurt is lower in lactose than regular yogurt and higher in protein, so it sits better with most dogs. If your dog still reacts to dairy, skip this one. Our guide on which yogurt is safe for dogs covers the details. (Note: that cross-link applies; if you want a fuller frozen lineup, see below.)
Freeze two ripe bananas, then blend them until smooth. That is the whole recipe. It tastes ice-cream-like, has no added sugar, and most dogs go for it. A spoon of natural peanut butter (xylitol-free) makes it richer.
Pour low-sodium, no-onion, no-garlic bone broth into an ice cube tray and freeze. Savory rather than sweet, and a lot of dogs prefer it to anything dairy. Zero sugar.
For more frozen ideas and a side-by-side on the better store options, our best frozen dog treats guide is a good next stop, and the summer frozen treats rundown covers hot-weather use.
Match the option to the situation:
The standard rule is that treats should make up no more than 10 percent of a dog's daily calories. For a 30-pound dog eating roughly 800 calories a day, that is about 80 treat calories. One Frosty Paws cup at 140 to 150 calories blows past that on its own.
This is the single biggest reason to consider an alternative. It is not that Frosty Paws is dangerous, it is that one cup can crowd out the rest of the day's treats and tip an at-risk dog toward weight gain. Smaller, lower-calorie frozen treats let you reward your dog more often without the same trade-off.
Whatever you pick, store-bought or homemade, steer clear of:
We started Cooper's Treats because we looked at the frozen dog treat aisle and saw the same thing a lot of owners notice: nearly everything was built to look and taste like ice cream, which meant dairy, sugar, and a lot of calories. That is fine for a birthday. It is not what we wanted to feed our own dogs week after week.
Our answer was the Pupsicle: real meat, freeze-dried so it keeps in the pantry, that you mix with water and freeze in silicone molds. Each Pupsicle is about 20 calories, has no added sugar, and no dairy, so most dogs can have a couple a day without it touching their main meals. The work is about 60 seconds of stirring and pouring for a week's worth of treats. If you want the whole setup, the Pupsicle Starter Kit comes with mix, a mold, and a jar. The chicken and sweet potato mix is our most popular flavor, and if you already have mix and just want better molds, the paw and bone silicone mold set works with any of the homemade recipes above too.
If your dog has had loose stools after Frosty Paws, dairy is the most likely cause. Switching to a dairy-free frozen treat usually clears it up, and you can confirm by reintroducing dairy later in a small amount.
Get 10% off your first order when you sign up for updates from us. We solemnly vow not to spam you or share your email.
