Your Cart is Empty
FREE DELIVERY | 100% HAPPINESS GUARANTEE
FREE DELIVERY | 100% HAPPINESS GUARANTEE
December 31, 2020 8 min read
TL;DR: "Real meat" on a dog treat label is loosely regulated, and what counts as meat varies wildly. The first ingredient by weight tells you the most. "Meat" must be actual muscle tissue, "meat meal" is rendered (dried, ground), "meat byproduct" includes organs and non-muscle parts, and "animal digest" is a vague flavoring. None of these are necessarily bad, but quality varies a lot. Look for named species ("chicken" not "poultry"), short ingredient lists, no vague flavor terms, and "complete" or "balanced" nutrition statements if relevant.
"Made with real meat" is everywhere on dog treat packaging. But what does it actually mean, and how much of the treat is actually meat?
The answer is: it depends, and not always in ways you'd expect. The dog food industry uses specific regulatory terms that look similar but mean very different things. Understanding the difference between "chicken," "chicken meal," "chicken byproduct," and "chicken flavor" can change which treats you trust.
Here at Cooper's Treats, we built our products around real meat as a core ingredient because we wanted to give dogs treats that actually reflected the marketing. This guide walks through what the various meat-related label terms mean, how to read a dog treat ingredient list, what to look for, and what to avoid.
The phrase "real meat" isn't a defined regulatory term. It's marketing language. Brands use it to suggest that the product contains actual meat (as opposed to flavoring or byproducts), but there's no legal standard that "real meat" must meet.
What IS regulated is what individual ingredients can be called. AAFCO (the Association of American Feed Control Officials) defines the specific terms manufacturers use on ingredient lists. So while "real meat" on the front of a package tells you almost nothing, the ingredient list on the back tells you a lot, if you know how to read it.
The single most useful question to ask: what's the first ingredient?
Here are the AAFCO definitions, in plain English:
Meat is the clean flesh of slaughtered animals, specifically the striated muscle. Can include attached fat, skin, sinew, nerves, and blood vessels. Generally good. When you see "chicken" as the first ingredient, that's actual chicken muscle tissue.
Important caveat: meat is roughly 70% water by weight. When it's listed first on the label, the cooking or processing removes much of that water, so the actual contribution to the final product can be less than it looks. Still, real meat as the first ingredient is generally a positive sign.
Meat meal is rendered meat, meaning the meat has been cooked, dried, and ground into a concentrated powder. The water has already been removed, so the actual protein content per pound is much higher than fresh meat.
"Chicken meal" is generally a high-quality ingredient. It's chicken (muscle, skin, fat, sinew) that's been dried and concentrated. Some premium dog foods actually prefer named meat meals over fresh meat for this reason, you get more protein per pound.
The catch: meal quality varies by source. Reputable manufacturers use named species meals from quality sources. Cheap manufacturers can use lower-quality rendering byproducts.
Byproducts include the non-muscle parts of the animal, organs (liver, kidneys, lungs, spleen, brain), blood, bone, and other parts that aren't typically eaten by humans in the US. Excludes feathers, hair, horns, hooves, teeth, and intestinal contents.
Byproducts have a bad reputation, but they're not necessarily bad. Organ meats are actually nutrient-dense, and dogs have evolved to eat whole prey, including organs. Liver, in particular, is rich in vitamins and minerals.
The problem with "byproducts" as a label term is the variability. High-quality byproducts (specific organs from healthy animals) are nutritious. Low-quality byproducts (whatever's left at a rendering plant) are less so. Without more specificity, you don't know which you're getting.
The rendered, dried version of byproducts. Same considerations as byproducts, but in concentrated form. Quality varies based on the source.
The vaguest term in the bunch. "Animal digest" is the result of breaking down animal tissue with enzymes or acids, creating a liquid flavoring spray that gets applied to dry food to make it taste better. The "animal" can be a mix of species. It's a flavoring, not a meaningful protein source.
If a treat lists "animal digest" instead of a named meat source, the treat probably doesn't have much meat in it, and the "real meat" claim on the front is mostly marketing.
If a label just says "meat" or "poultry" without naming the species, the manufacturer has reserved the right to use whatever's cheapest at the time. That can change batch to batch. Generally a yellow flag, especially if your dog has allergies (you can't know what they're reacting to).
The most misleading label term, hands down. By AAFCO standards, "chicken flavor" only requires that the food be recognizable as chicken-flavored, but doesn't require the food to actually contain meaningful amounts of chicken. The flavor can come from chicken digest, broth, or even synthetic flavoring.
If you see "chicken flavor" as an ingredient instead of "chicken" or "chicken meal," the actual chicken content in the food is minimal.
Ingredient lists are required to be in descending order by weight. The first ingredient is by far the most prevalent. The fifth ingredient, less so. The fifteenth ingredient, usually a tiny percentage.
So when a brand says "made with real chicken" and chicken is the fifteenth ingredient, you can do the math: the treat is essentially flavored with chicken, not made of chicken.
What you want, for a "real meat" treat:
Here's a sneaky one. Manufacturers sometimes split a single ingredient (especially grains and fillers) into multiple slightly different forms so each individual form weighs less than the main ingredient and gets pushed down the list.
Example: a treat might list "chicken" first, but then have "ground corn," "corn gluten meal," and "corn flour" as ingredients 2, 4, and 6. If you added up all the corn, it might outweigh the chicken. But because they're split, chicken appears to be the dominant ingredient.
Watch for splitting. Add up similar ingredients to get a real sense of what's in the treat.
A quick scan to assess quality:
Sixty seconds, and you'll know whether a treat is what its packaging claims to be.
Red flags on a dog treat label:
Green flags:
"Human grade" is technically a regulated term. For a dog food or treat to legally claim "human grade," every single ingredient must be human-edible and the product must be manufactured in a facility approved for human food production. That's a high bar.
If a treat is genuinely human-grade, it's usually a positive indicator. The catch is that some brands use "human grade ingredients" (which only means the individual ingredients are human-grade), which is a weaker claim. Look for the specific language.
Grain-free was a hot trend for years, but the science has gotten more complicated. The FDA has investigated a potential link between certain grain-free diets and a heart condition (dilated cardiomyopathy) in dogs, particularly when those diets are heavy in legumes (peas, lentils, chickpeas).
For most dogs, grains aren't a problem. The "grains are bad" narrative was largely marketing. If your dog has a confirmed grain allergy (rare), grain-free makes sense. Otherwise, focus on protein quality, not grain status.
Generally yes, with some caveats:
Caveats:
Here at Cooper's Treats, we believe two things: homemade treats are usually better than store-bought, and real meat is the best foundation for a dog treat. That's why we built our products around freeze-dried real meat. You add water, you mix, you bake or freeze, and you've got a real-meat treat with a short ingredient list and no fillers.
Our Baked Biscuit Starter Kit gives you fresh, homemade dog biscuits in about 25 minutes, with real meat (beef, turkey, or lamb depending on flavor) as a core ingredient. No vague digest. No splitting tricks. No mystery flavorings. Just real ingredients you can actually identify.
If you'd rather buy treats off the shelf, that's fine too, but use the 60-second scan above to evaluate them. Make sure the front-of-package "real meat" claim matches what's actually on the back of the package.
"Real meat" is marketing language with no specific legal meaning. What matters is the ingredient list. Look for named meats ("chicken" not "poultry") in the top ingredients, named meals for concentrated protein, and a short overall list. Avoid "animal digest," vague unspecified meats, "[species] flavor" instead of the species, added sugars, and toxic ingredients. Watch for ingredient splitting that hides fillers. Most "real meat" treats with a named meat as the first ingredient are a meaningful step up from filler-based competitors. When in doubt, single-ingredient freeze-dried treats are the simplest way to know exactly what you're feeding your dog.
Get 10% off your first order when you sign up for updates from us. We solemnly vow not to spam you or share your email.
